Friday, April 24, 2026

Game #25 - Cleveland Guardians (15-12) @ Toronto Blue Jays (10-15) - game recap

 

Andres Gimenez hit a 2-run double in a losing effort as the Guardians held on to defeat the Blue Jays 8-6

After an off-day/travel day yesterday, the Blue Jays opened a week long home stand as they welcomed the Clevelsnd Guardians to town. The Blue Jays and Guardians split the season series last year with the Blue Jays outscoring the Guardians 32-24. Max Scherzer got the start with Tyler Heineman behind the plate. Vlad was back in the field after serving as DH Wednesday (Lenyn Sosa served as DH tonight). Jesus Sanchez was in LF and Nathan Lukes was in RF. Could the Blue Jays start the weekend and homestand with a win? Here is today's game recap.

Game Highlights:

  • The Guardians opened the scoring in the top of the 1st as Daniel Schneeman led off the game with a solo jack to right and into the Guardians bullpen
  • Four batters later, George Valera doubled scoring Jose Ramirez and Rhys Hoskins
  • A batter later, Angel Martinex whacked a 2-run blast to right-center; also scoring Valera
  • Nathan Lukes left the game in the bottom half of the inning with an injured hamstring
  • Two batters later, Davis Schneider scored on a ground out hit by Vladimir Guerrero Jr.
  • A batter later, Jesus Sanchez hammered a solo bomb to dead center
  • The Blue Jays got one back in the bottom half of the inning as Kazuma Okamoto drilled a solo bomb to straightaway center
  • The Guardians added a pair of runs in the top of the 3rd as Martinez smacked a 2-run blast to right-center; also scoring Hoskins
  • Max Scherzer pitching line: 2.1IP 6H 7R (all earned) 3BB 0K 82 pitches (51 for strikes)
  • The Blue Jays got one back in the bottom of the 5th as Ernie Clement doubled scoring Schneider
  • The Guardians added a run in the top of the 6th on a fielder's choice hit by Chase DeLauter
  • The Blue Jays got a pair back in the bottom half of the inning as Andres Gimenez doubled scoring Lenyn Sosa and Okamoto\
  • Gavin Williams pitching line: 6IP 7H 6R (all earned) 2BB 4K 96 pitches (63 for strikes)\
  • Cade Smith pitched a scoreless 9th for his 6th save of the season
  • Final score: Guardians 8 Blue Jays 6
My Take:

  • Neither starting pitcher was exactly stellar tonight. Scherzer may be nearing the end of his time and potentially career with Trey Yesavage and Jose Berrios both nearing a return from the IL. Scherzer was lit up for 7 runs on 6 hits while walking 3 and striking out none over 2.1 innings. Clearly he didn't have it tonight. Was his forearm barking at him, was it lack of command or simply a day where he didn't have his best stuff going for him. With Yesavage very close to returning, one of Scherzer or Lauer will come out of the rotation. One or both could be put on the IL since both have been playing through things. One or both could be DFA'd with both pitchers out of options. It will be interesting to see if Lauer or Scherzer are yanked from the rotation first.
  • The bullplen gave up a run on 4 hits while walking one and striking out 8 over the last 6.2 innings.This might have been a good situation for Jeff Hoffman, who is being removed from the closer's role for now, to pitch in given the game was pretty out of reach, though the Blue Jays did chip away at the deficit and had a chance to tie in the 9th but came up short. Mason Fluharty and Tommy Nance both retired every batter they faced and combined for 5 strikesouts over 2 innings
  • The offense is slowly showing signs of the oomph it showed in 2025 when they were never really out of games. Davis Schneider (2 runs scored), Andres Gimenez (2-run double), Kazuma Okamoto (2 runs scored, including a solo HR) and Jesus Sanchez did the damage today.
  • The Blue Jays were 1-7 with runners in scoring position
  • The Blue Jays were 4-5 in ABS challenges, Davis Schneider and Tyler Heineman had both their challenges successfully overturned with Schneider overturnin 2 strike calls into balls and Heineman overturning 2 ball calls into strikes for his pitchers. Guardians catcher Bo Naylor was unsuccessful in his lone ABS challenge with the ball call being confirmed
  • Up next, the Blue Jays try to snap the 2-game skid, even the series and avoid their 7th series loss of the season. Ace Kevin Gausman starts against Gaurdians lefty Joey Cantillo